So I watched the 2-hour documentary entitled ‘Dark Girls’ that aired on the Oprah Winfrey Network. When I first heard of this documentary, I was hella excited. “Yes, let’s talk about it!”, I thought. I actually welcome discussions like this simply because I do not believe we have appropriately addressed or dealt with the mental affects of slavery, such as colorism, within the black community.
I was very optimistic about how great this documentary would be, however, about one hour into the documentary my optimism faded and excitement turned into disappointment. I expected a fairly thorough (2 hour) discussion about colorism, its origin, its affects and how we can rise above by letting go of Eurocentric beauty standards…but I hardly saw any of that.
Instead I saw a bunch of (seemingly) depressed dark skinned women with low self-esteem, and a bunch of black men who “prefer” to date light skinned women. Womp.
This documentary fueled the negative propaganda we see on a daily basis. The entire documentary carried an undertone of “dark skinned girls are insecure and have low self-esteem”, “black men do not like dark skinned girls” and “white men know how to find beauty in/appreciate dark skin” (the ‘white savior’ undertone annoyed me most). Not to mention the lack of history presented. They took about 5-10 minutes at the very beginning to mention things like the “brown paper bag test” and they may have said the word “slavery” once… but it seemed that the main message was that black people fuel colorism. (While I do not particularly disagree, I think that it is very important that we understand where the skin tone division came from.)
The documentary hardly showed any images of dark skinned women who loved themselves, black men who loved us, or strong black families. It made us dark skinned women look weak, in my opinion.
We certainly didn’t need anyone else to highlight or reinforce feelings of insecurity or inferiority among black women and we most definitely didn’t need anyone fueling gender wars within the black community (which this documentary did, based on the numerous tweets I saw damning black men to hell and suggesting that white men were the answer).
The documentary offered no insight for moving forward, and getting past this slave mentality. As a matter of fact, I don’t remember any of the women saying the words “I am beautiful” at all, throughout the entire 2 hours. What was the point of bringing up skin tone if the beauty of black women was not emphasized?
The scenes with the little girls who didn’t “want to be black” or who thought that light skin was prettier and smarter were heart wrenching. I really hope that someone was able to have a talk with those beautiful children to let them know that they are in no way, shape or form ugly or dumb. That they never have been and that they never will be. I would hate for those harmful mentalities to go uncorrected.
The male perspectives of this documentary were annoying. 90% of the black males interviewed did not like dark skinned women and all of the white men just loved us. *rolls eyes* All that money ya’ll have, and you couldn’t give us more positive examples of black men who love black women? Ridiculous. I also noticed that many of the black men interviewed had very ignorant perspectives… while the white men dropped jewels about OUR community and OUR women. Where they do that at? Oh yeah, on TV.
The “love yourself” message came literally within the last 4 minutes of the documentary, obviously not a high priority item for the producers.
And I can’t help but mention the network’s timely placement of “skin enhancement” commercials during every commercial break. What are you tryna say, Oprah? Subliminals, much?
All in all I can’t say that I absolutely hated the documentary (a couple of people dropped a couple of jewels… just a couple… and at least they gave us some shine… I guess) but….
Oprah and friends, I’m gonna need for you to do better!
Let’s discuss our history, our beauty, our strengths. Let’s close the gender divide in the black community, not exacerbate it. Let’s hear about strong, positive black families who practice self-love. Let’s do better.




